Should I Subtract Fiber From Carbs?

Most Recent Update: May 17, 2024

Explore why fiber is considered within your carbohydrate intake when practicing IIFYM, and why it's crucial to manage both components separately for effective weight loss and dietary tracking.

When it comes to IIFYM and fiber, there is no additional math. With IIFYM and weight loss, we base everything off of the gross amount of carbohydrates, not net carbs. Losing weight is all about the gross amount of food we eat, which is why there’s no reason to subtract fiber from carbs.

So, when you get your macros from the IIFYM calculator, keep this in mind so you’re focused on only the essential aspects.

Why You Don’t Subtract Fiber with IIFYM

If your macro diet dictates that hit 150 grams of carbs and 30 grams of fiber, you do just that. At the end of the day, on your weight loss log, make sure that you have eaten 150 grams of carbs and 30 grams of fiber.

  • Not 120 carbs and 30 fiber
  • Not 180 carbs and 30 fiber

If you care about weight loss, 30 grams of your carbs should be fiber, and they still count as calories (for our example).

A side-view of a woman in a grey tank top and black shorts performing a pull-up on a power rack in a professional gym setting.

The way your body digests your carbs is not of concern to us. The glycemic index of the carbs, nor the sugar content, nor the type of sugar is a concern. All we care about is the fiber content. So at the end of the day, just make sure that you hit your fiber and your carbs separately.

You will find, however, that since carbohydrates and fiber are connected, that this can be tricky at first. If you have a hard time getting all of your fiber in, you might want to try using a fiber supplement. Just be sure to log it, since there are calories in fiber and as you know. Calories = Fat gain if you are in a surplus!

 

In This Article

WANT A COMPLETE MACRO STRATEGY?
Turn your macros into an actual plan.
Get a structured strategy for setting, tracking, and adjusting your macros without jumping straight into 1:1 coaching.
SEE THE MACRO BLUEPRINT
No rigid meal plan. No generic macro percentages.
Hungry at night while tracking macros for fat loss

Hungry at Night While Tracking Macros? How to Plan Your Meals By Anthony Collova, founder of IIFYM.com You’ve finished dinner, logged your food, and hit your macros. An hour later, you’re standing in the kitchen wondering what else you can eat. If that keeps happening, your food log deserves a

15 Min Reading

Weight-loss-and-addiction

What Hitting Rock Bottom in Addiction Taught Me About Macros and Weight Loss 28 years clean and sober, and I still lean into this tool. By Anthony Collova, Founder of IIFYM.com As the founder of IIFYM, I spend a lot of time writing about weight loss, macros, nutrition, dieting and

15 Min Reading

Macro dieting mistakes

Tracking Macros After a Binge: Why I Tell My Clients to Log the Bad Days By Anthony Collova, founder of IIFYM.com and creator of the original IIFYM macro calculator. Written from 15 years of one-on-one macro coaching. Reviewed for accuracy and updated for 2026. One of the first things I

15 Min Reading

IIFYM.com Macros & Fitness
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.